#19 Marketplace Moats in the Age of AI
For years marketplace startups have relied on a familiar playbook: achieve liquidity, build network effects, and scale defensibly. But as AI reshapes nearly every part of how products are built, discovered, and delivered, it’s worth asking the question: Are network effects still the dominant moat for marketplaces?
The short answer: yes, but there are several other AI moats marketplace founders should consider building into their plans.
1. Classic Moat: Network Effects (Still Relevant, But Evolving)
Network effects are one of the biggest value-creating features of a marketplace– the usefulness of the marketplace increases with each additional participant, typically via increased liquidity and improved matching.
AI Factor: AI reduces friction in discovery and matching. Multi-homing (listing supply on multiple sites or customers searching multiple sites) becomes easier with AI tools.
Response: As a result, marketplaces with physical assets now have an advantage – e.g., for Uber, while route optimization and driver matching are now easier algorithms to build, building two-sided density of drivers with cars and human car-riders is still a formidable moat. On the other hand, an online marketplace dealing wholly in digital assets would be much easier for AI solutions to displace.
2. Data Network Effects (More Important Than Ever)
As users interact with a marketplace platform, it accumulates proprietary transaction data that can be used to improve the experience for future users, creating data network effects.
AI Factor: General AI models like GPT-4 can generate responses, but can’t match the performance of systems trained on rich, structured, proprietary transaction data.
Response: Proprietary data is more important than ever. As an example, StockX uses proprietary transaction data to provide dynamic real-time pricing recommendations, forecast demand spikes/inventory shortages, and detect counterfeit/fraud to improve trust. This topic deserves more ink, we’ll write more about marketplace data moats in a subsequent post.
3. Workflow Lock-In (Quiet but Durable)
Some of the best marketplaces we’ve invested in have embedded software tools into their users' daily workflows to become difficult to displace. As an example of successful embedded software, Backlot Cars (marketplace for dealers to buy and sell used cars) offered dealers an app that allowed them to capture robust vehicle inspection data on cars they were selling and tools to manage their inventory and pricing.
AI Factor: AI has made workflow automation easier than ever. If marketplaces don’t vertically integrate they leave the door open for another SaaS software provider to embed their tools.
Response: Marketplaces still own demand, which is arguably more important to businesses, but it is hard to displace embedded competitive software once a business has been trained on a set of tools. For marketplace startups, not building embedded software is a lost opportunity to be the first-mover and possibly create a second more predictable SaaS revenue stream on top of transaction revenue.
4. Atomic Network Density (Still Core to Liquidity)
Marketplaces win by achieving dense liquidity in atomic units (e.g., a city, vertical, or job type).
AI Factor: While AI can accelerate growth and supply onboarding, it can’t shortcut the trust and reliability that comes from deep liquidity in a given niche or geography.
Response: Local marketplaces with physical assets are pretty AI resistant. Instacart, DoorDash, and Thumbtack all need critical mass in specific neighborhoods and then are defensible. AI might improve routing or matching, but local density still rules.
5. Brand & Trust Flywheels (More Valuable in the Generative Age)
Trust—through reviews, ratings, safety protocols, and guarantees—compounds over time, creating a moat that AI can't easily replicate.
AI Factor: As generative AI makes fraud and impersonation easier, platforms with high brand trust and safety layers will stand out.
Response: Airbnb's defensibility doesn't just come from supply, but from a decade of trust-building via verified profiles, user reviews, and a global safety infrastructure.
6. Vertical Specialization (Where General AI Falls Short)
Focused marketplaces build domain-specific tools, UX, and curation that outperform general-purpose platforms.
Response: Domain-specific training beats general models in high-stakes or nuanced verticals. Trust, language, workflows, and regulation matter.
7. Embedded FinTech (Proprietary Data Enables Better Decisions)
Embedded fintech can be a powerful tool to unlock both supply and demand.
Response: For vendors, access to capital enables purchasing more inventory and, in turn, selling more in a marketplace. Similarly, for business buyers, access to more capital allows buyers to buy more products. Access to proprietary transaction data allows marketplaces to uniquely compete with a superior data advantage to generic AI powered lending platforms.
What Endures in the Age of AI?
AI is transforming how marketplaces operate—but not how they win. Liquidity, trust, and data still matter. Founders can look beyond network effects to build even more moats: workflows that create habits, data that sharpens recommendations, and vertical expertise that AI can’t easily mimic. From an investor perspective, the most promising marketplace startups won’t just connect supply and demand—they’ll layer intelligence, infrastructure, and trust in ways that make switching feel impossible. In the age of AI, the best marketplaces won't just be big. They'll be smart, sticky, and impossible to clone.
Weekly Deals
Meet with us
We’re on the move, and love to meet with founders and investors in person. Reach out to contact@snak.vc:
May 21 | virtual - Sonia is a featured guest today at 12pm CT at an Everything Marketplace Female Founders Group meeting. If you’re not already an EM community member you can follow the instructions here to get access to the chat.
May 22 | NYC - we will be at VSC’s Dirty Jobs Summit and would love to meet with founders and investors before and after
June 6 | Chicago - we are judging University of Chicago Booth’s Global New Venture Challenge
June 25 - 27 | Indiana - Great Lakes Venture Summit