#22 Beyond Take Rate: Frameworks for Marketplace Pricing + Growth
When thinking about how best to monetize their marketplace, most founders default to a take rate because it’s simple and familiar. As marketplaces mature and participants get savvier, pricing becomes both a competitive moat and a growth limiter. In a world where platforms face pressure to offer more services, gain trust, and justify their margin– pricing is product. The most successful marketplaces are constantly revisiting how they charge, who they charge, and when.
At a high level, there are 5 ways marketplaces monetize:
1. Take Rate (Classic)
Best for: Transactional, high-frequency marketplaces with price transparency.
Example: Etsy, AirBnB.
Watch out for: Margin compression, backlash from power sellers.
2. SaaS + Take Rate Hybrid
Best for: Supply-side software tools + transaction monetization.
Example: Faire (CRM + marketplace), Mindbody.
Why it works: Locks in suppliers and monetizes network activity.
3. Lead Gen / Pay-Per-Contact
Best for: Services where transactions are offline or high-trust.
Example: Thumbtack, HomeAdvisor.
Risk: Can feel extractive if quality of leads are inconsistent.
4. Subscription Access (Either Side)
Best for: High-value matches where discovery is the product.
Example: G2 (for software vendors), The Mom Project (for employers), Raya (for users), Blueboard (experiences for HR).
Note: Works well where exclusivity or curated access matters.
5. Embedded Financial Services
Best for: Marketplaces with high transaction value or operational complexity.
Example: Outdoorsy (insurance + financing), Turo (protection packages), Upwork (payment escrow).
Angle: Trust layer doubles as monetization layer.
Framework: How to Choose the Right Pricing Model
Every pricing strategy starts with four fundamental questions:
Who pays?
→ Supply, demand, or both?What are they paying for?
→ Access to the network? Tools? A successful transaction?When do they pay?
→ Upfront, per use, post-match, or recurring?How much do they pay?
→ Flat fee, percentage of GMV, tiered based on volume or category?
These questions shape everything from user incentives to LTV to CAC payback. And they all interrelate—change one, and you often need to rebalance the others. Diving deeper into each of these:
1. Who Pays?
Your choice here often reflects supply/demand power dynamics. For example, in commoditized labor markets, supply pays to access work. In premium services, demand is willing to pay for trusted access.
2. How Is the Fee Structured?
Take rates are the most common model, but not always the most efficient. Subscriptions often work better for SaaS-like marketplaces with frequent or recurring usage.
3. When Do You Charge?
Timing influences adoption: per-transaction pricing aligns incentives, but upfront charges can ensure quality of supply and/or demand, build commitment and predictability.
Pricing Levers for Growth
Once your base model is set, here are levers you can test to drive growth:
The best marketplaces iterate on pricing just like they do with their product.
Strategic Tradeoffs
Pricing is never just a math problem. It’s also behavioral economics and trust-building. Consider:
Friction vs. Monetization:
A higher take rate might increase revenue… or drive users off-platform.Simplicity vs. Precision:
Flat pricing is easier to communicate; dynamic pricing is often more fair (but harder to explain).Power User Capture:
Consider custom pricing or account management for your top-tier supply or demand.
Founders — we’d love to hear from you: How are you approaching pricing in your marketplace? What’s worked well? What surprised you? Drop a comment or message us at contact@snak.vc.
Weekly Deals
What We’re Reading
PillPack founders’ new health care marketplace has deep roots with Amazon - Stat - The founders behind PillPack have launched a telehealth marketplace combining direct medical services and telemedicine—showing how marketplace models can redefine healthcare delivery.
Live‑shopping platform Whatnot adds a wholesale function - Modern Retail -Whatnot, the U.S. live‑stream auction marketplace, rolled out a new wholesale feature, enabling sellers to move bulk inventory — a strong signal of the category scaling its supply-side options and tapping into reseller dynamics.
Colin Gardiner’s Marketplace Memo #12 - Take Rate - Colin’s latest covers thoughts on AI-powered dev tools and no-code platforms and implications of Meta’s move on Scale AI.
Meet with us
We’re on the move, and love to meet with founders and investors in person. Reach out to contact@snak.vc:
June 20 | Kansas City
June 25 - 27 | Indiana - Great Lakes Venture Summit
July 21 - 25 | Chicago TechWeek