#21 5 Principles for Building Data Moats in Marketplaces
In the age of generative AI and increased platform competition, proprietary data and products built on top of proprietary data prevail as the most important sustainable advantage a marketplace can build. Founders benefit from being intentional about designing platforms that generate proprietary, high-signal, and compounding data over time. Here are 5 key principles to think through:
1. Design the Product to Generate Proprietary Data
Your UX should incentivize behavior that produces useful data:
Structured actions (vs freeform): Instead of just a text message, use quote requests, availability pickers, or booking flows.
Force metadata: Require SKUs, service details, location, turnaround time, etc. at listing time.
Incentivize feedback loops: Use reviews, ratings, completion confirmations, or NPS to measure quality on both sides.
Goal: Capture user intent, supply-side capacity, and transaction outcomes in a way that can't be scraped or easily copied. This data helps fuel matching, trust, and automation engines.
2. Capture the Full Funnel — Not Just the End Point
The value of data is not just the transaction. Track the entire decision-making process:
Searches that didn’t convert
Messages sent without a booking
Listings viewed but skipped
This kind of behavioral data is incredibly valuable for:
Improving recommendations and search ranking
Identifying supply gaps
Informing new seller acquisition priorities
3. Bring Off-Platform Behavior On-Platform
To own the full customer journey, marketplaces must reduce leakage and encourage more of the buyer/seller interaction to happen in-product.
Tactics:
Offer built-in payments, scheduling, communication, and support
Use loyalty rewards, volume-driven incentives, or guarantees to make staying on-platform more attractive
Provide usage-based coaching: "Vendors with updated calendars book 2x more often"
Why it matters: The more activity happens on-platform, the more defensible and proprietary your data becomes.
4. Turn Data into Product Features
Data isn’t a moat unless it’s operationalized. Feed it into product loops that drive user value:
Matchmaking algorithms
Smart filters and search ranking
Dynamic pricing or availability
Fraud and trust signals
Examples:
Upwork uses data on past contracts to rank freelancers in search
Faire personalizes brand discovery based on buyer history
Airbnb uses data to score listing quality and reduce fraud
5. Productize Data Back to Sellers
The most advanced marketplaces turn their data into tools for their vendors:
Market insights (e.g. trending products or buyer behavior)
Seller benchmarking (e.g. "Your prices are 20% above average")
Forecasting tools (e.g. seasonal demand predictors)
This creates stickiness. Your sellers won’t just rely on you for transactions—you become their operating system / business dashboard.
Examples:
StockX offers price history charts and volatility graphs
DoorDash predicts delivery windows using historical fleet data
Faire tells brands when to restock based on demand forecasting
G2 provides buyer intent data to software vendors
Data moats aren’t just a nice-to-have; they’re core to defensibility in modern marketplaces. The best marketplaces aren’t just software wrappers for supply and demand—they’re learning engines. And the more data they see, the smarter and harder to copy they become.
How are you building a data moat in your marketplace?
Whether you're using AI to personalize recommendations or capturing unique supply-side signals, we’d love to hear how you're turning marketplace data into defensibility. Drop a comment below or email us at contact@snak.vc.
Weekly Deals
What We’re Reading
Taskrabbit CEO Ania Smith Isn’t Afraid of AI Robots Replacing Human Labor - The Verge - Taskrabbit is leaning into AI to improve matching and leverage digital assistants, not replace human "Taskers." Their end‑to‑end service model emphasizes quality and supply-side control—offering insight on how marketplaces can integrate AI while preserving human value.
3 Tips to Help Your Startup Survive the Age of AI, from Anthropic's Product Chief - Business Insider - Why it matters: Mike Krieger (Anthropic’s CPO and Instagram cofounder) outlines three strategies for startups: focus on deep domain expertise, build personalized customer relationships, and explore unconventional AI interfaces. Great guidance for marketplaces building defensible, AI-resistant models.
News Sites Are Getting Crushed by Google’s New AI Tools - WSJ - News organizations are preparing for a world in which SEO traffic goes to zero. How are you building traffic that’s more durable in an answers driven world, rather than a search driven world?
Meet with us
We’re on the move, and love to meet with founders and investors in person. Reach out to contact@snak.vc:
June 12 | Chicago - Innovating Building Materials and Supply Chain Conference
June 12 | Chicago - Fighting for Futures fundraiser
June 25 - 27 | Indiana - Great Lakes Venture Summit
July 21 - 25 | Chicago - Chicago TechWeek